The Creatine Chronicles: Science, Strength, and Surprises

Shai Amar

20 Apr 2025 • 5 min read

Creatine is that supplement you've probably heard gym bros swear by, but it turns out it's not just for bench-pressing bros or people who think leg day is optional. This deep-dive, told in the emotionally intelligent, explores what science actually says about creatine: not just the gains, but the brain, the myths, the mood, and even the hair (yes, we go there). Spanning meta-analyses and multi-year trials, the story shows how this humble molecule might just be the most misunderstood superhero of sports nutrition. It makes you faster, stronger, maybe even smarter – and guess what? It’s safe, too. But we’re not just selling you on it. We’re walking you through the tears, triumphs, and randomized controlled trials. Because in the end, this isn’t just about supplements – it’s about how we fuel the bodies and minds that carry us through life.

So grab your metaphorical lab coat (or protein shake), and let’s dive in.

Creatine – The Nerdfighter of Supplements

Let me tell you a story about a molecule. A tiny, nitrogenous compound called creatine that lives in your muscle cells, fuels your sprint, and maybe—just maybe—keeps your brain from short-circuiting when you haven’t slept in 24 hours. This is the story of creatine monohydrate. It is not a love story. Except, maybe, it kind of is.

Back in the 90s, creatine was that suspicious powder in the locker room that made football players bulk up overnight and parents worry about their sons growing third arms. But in the decades since, scientists got curious. And they did what scientists do: randomized controlled trials, meta-analyses, and debates in academic journals with names like The Journal of Applied Physiology and Nutrients (which, by the way, is basically Vogue for biochem nerds).

So what did they find? A lot, actually.

They found that creatine increases the amount of phosphocreatine in your muscles by 15–40%. What’s that mean in human terms? More fuel for short bursts of high-intensity activity – lifting, sprinting, or, I don’t know, chasing your kid across the playground after eating three Oreos and realizing you made a mistake.

But here's the twist: it doesn’t just help young gym rats. In over 22 trials involving older adults—yes, Grandma and Grandpa Creatine—adding creatine to their resistance training helped them gain more lean mass and strength than exercise alone. And this wasn’t just a fluke. The results held across men and women, young and old, athletes and non-athletes. There’s no one-size-fits-all in life, but creatine comes close.

And let’s talk about the brain. In vegetarians (whose diets naturally lack creatine), supplementation improved working memory and fluid intelligence. In sleep-deprived adults, it helped people think clearly and feel less like emotionally compromised zombies. And in women with major depression? Creatine worked alongside antidepressants to improve symptoms faster and more completely. That’s not hype – that’s peer-reviewed, placebo-controlled science.

Of course, there were controversies. The infamous "creatine makes you bald" study showed a rise in DHT—a hormone linked to hair loss—in rugby players. But that tiny study has never been replicated. No, creatine doesn’t make you bald. At worst, it might make you notice your baldness if you were already headed there.

Then there were the kidney panic headlines. But across 25+ studies, including those involving diabetics and high-protein eaters, creatine didn’t harm kidneys. In fact, in a giant pooled safety review of 685 trials, creatine had the same side effect rate as placebo. Think about that. Taking nothing had the same chance of causing GI upset or cramps as taking creatine.

So why do we care? Because creatine isn’t just about biceps or Instagram gym selfies. It’s about aging gracefully, preserving muscle, boosting brain function, and possibly improving quality of life when you’re tired, stressed, or struggling. It’s not magic. But it’s close.

And like all good old stories, there’s a metaphor. Creatine is the reliable sidekick—the Robin (Batman says hi) of your mitochondria. It won’t cure everything, but it helps you live a little better, push a little further, and maybe, just maybe, not forget to be awesome.

Okay? Okay.

Citations:

Creatine – The Nerdfighter of Supplements

Citations:

Sign up for more like this.